How we choose.
Thirty-one places visited. Six listed. This is the story of the other twenty-five, and the four rules that decided it.

Fallow began with a bad year and a good week. In 2021 Aoife Brennan spent seven days on a fishermen's quay in the Lofoten Islands, came home to Kendal and decided that rest was something you could go and find, if somebody had been there first.
Since then we have visited thirty-one places for a week or more each. We sleep in the bed, eat the food, walk the route in the wrong season and ask who else is at breakfast. Six places passed. Twenty-five did not, usually for a reason you can fix with money and sometimes for a reason you cannot.
That is the whole idea. We are a team of five in an office above a shop on Wildman Street, and we would rather sell six weeks we trust than sixty we have only read about.
Four rules, each one costly.
We go first
Aoife or one of the guides stays a week, sleeps in the bed and eats the food before we offer it.
In 2022 Aoife spent four nights in the room we meant to give our first guests in Ella. The mattress was too soft and the hot water ran out at seven. We changed both before we sold a single place.
We go back off-season
If it only works in July, it does not make the list. We return in the grey weeks.
Dolomites huts are busiest in July. We walked the Alta Via 1 in the last week of September, when the huts are closing and the weather is thin, to see what the route is like when nobody is trying to impress you. It held up, so a September departure is on the list.
We cap the group
Six to twelve people. Nobody queues for a hot tap or has to be introduced to the room.
In Kiso the minshuku seats eight at one low table. We have never taken nine. At Wadi Rum the camp has nine tents and the group is nine. A bigger number would have been easy to sell and would have changed the place.
We ask everyone after
Every guest gets one question: would you send a friend? Anything below yes gets a phone call.
After two early Cold Water Weeks, guests told us the sauna felt rushed. We split the group into two sessions of five, with the second one starting an hour later. The answer next time was yes.
What five years looks like.
Counted from our own spreadsheet, not rounded up. Fifty-eight per cent of guests have come back for a second week.
The twenty-five we turned down.
Every one of these was somewhere we stayed. Most were lovely. The reason is the one we wrote in our notes at the time.
- 01ValldemossaSpainLovely villa. Main road behind it.
- 02HallstattAustriaBeautiful, but ninety guests at breakfast.
- 03MeteoraGreeceStunning rock. Coach park at dawn.
- 04HvarCroatiaLovely island. Stag parties on the ferry.
- 05Isle of SkyeUnited KingdomFine light. Rain, every single day.
- 06ChefchaouenMoroccoBlue walls. Everyone filming them.
- 07EssaouiraMoroccoGood wind. Hotel had one tap.
- 08Aït BenhaddouMoroccoGreat kasbah. Hourly tour buses.
- 09Siwa OasisEgyptLovely oasis. Eleven hours by road.
- 10TozeurTunisiaPalm grove. Generator ran all night.
- 11Wadi MusaJordanPetra at noon. We left by lunch.
- 12GöremeTurkeyBalloons at six. Nobody sleeps.
- 13KaşTurkeyLovely harbour. Club music until three.
- 14MestiaGeorgiaTowers and snow. Road shut in March.
- 15KazbegiGeorgiaGlorious peak. Hotel faced a car park.
- 16LehIndiaThin air. Two guests needed oxygen.
- 17PushkarIndiaSacred lake. Sound system till midnight.
- 18HampiIndiaBoulders and ruins. Heat beyond our limit.
- 19MunnarIndiaTea hills, again. Ella does it better.
- 20SapaVietnamMisty terraces. Forty trekking agencies.
- 21Luang PrabangLaosGentle town. Bells at four, daily.
- 22Hoi AnVietnamLovely lanterns. Crowds after four.
- 23PaiThailandCheerful. Not the quiet we promise.
- 24ArashiyamaJapanBamboo grove. Ten thousand phones.
- 25NaoshimaJapanBrilliant art. Ferries full by ten.
Five people in Kendal.
We work above a shop on Wildman Street. You can ring any weekday and one of us will answer.
Aoife Brennan
Founder
Goes first to every place. Most of the thirty-one decisions are hers.
Read Aoife's wordsCallum Reid
Bookings
Holds your place, sends the invoice and answers questions about rooms.
Priya Nair
Travel and transfers
Plans the flights, trains and transfers around each week, door to door.
Eilidh Marsh
Guest care
Rings every guest before they go and every guest after they come home.
Ted Hollins
Accounts
Deals with deposits, balances and refunds. Replies faster than you would expect.